3. Select the discussion questions and the suggested assignments to use in the lesson. Many defendants who are not indigent do not want to pay the costs of a full-scale criminal trial. Guide the discussion to cover the following points, supplying information if the class cannot provide it: Finally, ask the class if they agree or disagree with the choices that society has made with respect to plea bargains and to support their conclusions. This impressive new film tells one woman's story of abuse at the hands of a hostile legal system. This product would be perfect for any art teac, In which John Green teaches you about America's "peculiar institution," slavery. Boot (2 Versions)3. Chris Weigant is a political commentator. What did the policemen at the gun range say about the people at the apartment complex during the, 6. The defendant forgoes the right to a trial and the requirement that he be convicted by a unanimous jury. Because of the stereotypes that surround her, Dee faces many struggles throughout her trial. Please revise and edit your paper for mechanical and grammatical errors. The $100,000 was the bail bondsmans fee, and it would never be returned, even if Alex won his trial. After refusing to agree to a plea bargain, the films heroine is bailed out of jail by her mother. Students will address the issues raised by plea bargaining through class discussion and writing assignments. American Violet opens in selected markets across the country this Friday, April 17th, including New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Washington D.C., Dallas, and Atlanta. Texas has become the first state to require that confidential informants must be corroborated. The movie begins with a mother waking and is trying to get her kids ready she is cooking breakfast and The ACLU lawyer is portrayed as a white knight, helping the powerless; but even he shows doubts when Dee asks if any of this will actually do any good. Any law enforcement action must be based upon some hard evidence rather than merely informant information; moreover, unreliable informant information should be discounted. Evaluate the plea bargaining system, describe the public policies which it serves and the public policy compromises that it requires, and express and justify an opinion about whether the plea bargaining system is, overall, good public policy, Students can research and write a formal essay or create a class presentation on the prisoners dilemma.. She thinks she is being arrested for her outstanding parking tickets. With considerable risk to her own future, Dee becomes the plaintiff in a class-action test case championed by ACLU attorney "David Cohen" (played by Tim Blake Nelson). 3. There are not enough prosecutors, public defenders, judges or courtrooms to handle the trials that would result if plea bargains were not permitted. Much of the action can be interpreted through visual cues, which supports our world language students. Get the free purple coloring page and worksheet here --> https://www.mpmschoolsupplies.com/ideas/7959/free-color-purple-worksheet/ S SupplyMe On the other hand, prosecutors who want to keep up their conviction rates, may agree to plea bargains that dont adequately punish a defendant and dont effectively deter crime. Dee experiences several hardships and setbacks in the movie and she is up against a very powerful force, the District Attorney. Please reference Error Code 2121 when contacting customer service. Though its politics are as obvious as its outcome, American Violet is an earnest docudrama about the justice system with a powerful performance from Nicole Behairie. Read critic reviews One good response is to make sure that the defense attorney is ethical and takes his or her responsibilities seriously. Which of the following are characteristics of state prisons? A look at plea bargaining from the standpoint of the victim and the victims friends and relatives. The criminal justice system in America enforces the standard conduct our country finds necessary to protect all of its citizens and lower crime. Multicultural Children signing words related to clothing. A Traditional Triad Color Scheme uses three evenly spaced Hues on the Basic Color Wheel. The lawyer advised Alex to plead out. Jim is driving. This can also take the form of a debate pro or con on the proposition: Plea bargaining should be replaced with a criminal justice system in which plea bargaining would not be allowed and an accused person could only plead guilty or go to trial. Color purple worksheets like this one are great for toddlers and preschoolers to practice color recognition, tracing skills, fine motor skills, and more. Listed are the artwork included: La Plume, Amerian Gothic, Girl with a Pearl Earring, Lady with Ermine, Mona Lisa, The Wave, Two Girls on a Terrance, Van Gogh's 1887 Self Portrait, Madame X, Sunflowers (1888), Milkmaid, Woman with a Veil, Crossing the Alps, and Violet. Ask the class to look at plea bargaining from the standpoint of the victim and the victims friends and relatives. If Alex got out in ten years, he could see his oldest daughter graduate from high school. The Post-Viewing Enrichment Worksheet is set out below. Besides courageous, what kind of qualities would you use to describe Dee? Heres how. However, prosecutors are usually judged on their conviction rate. Explain your reasons with reference to: (a) the concept that the result of the criminal process should be justice rather than the result of horse trading and (b) the fiscal impact and whether money would be better spent on other priorities. Alex was a middle-class man in his early 30s who was in the import-export business. These people are flawed in various ways, as are we all. She resists pressure to agree to a plea bargain. If it isnt getting enough light, the leaves will usually reach upward and have long petioles (leaf stems). A- They may lack resources for programming and prison industries. What happens at the meeting in the jail between Dee, her Public Defender, and the Prosecutor? This is about 31 minutes into the film. 3. I wouldn't really call it peculiar. Students may come up with their own thoughts and all well-reasoned responses are acceptable. The average response was that the regular movie attendant enjoyed the movie with 8.3 points and a. However, for other clients, they may have to choose between vigorous advocacy and maintaining a good relationship with the prosecutor. Your right to due process - fair treatment by the government whenever the loss of your liberty or property is at stake. She seems very well put together with a good head on her shoulders. The humanity of all the characters (including Xzibit, who appears in the film) is on display, for both the good guys and the bad guys. * State flags will soon be available for free. Dee then sinks to the floor of the cell with her head in her hands. american violet worksheet. Guide the discussion to cover the following points: Ask the class to state the policy choices made by society when it adopted a justice system based on plea bargains. (The bail was high because of the seriousness of the charge and because Alex was considered a flight risk. Multicultural Children signing words related to family. The movie is based on the true story of two women who were accused of Further information on theaters showing the film should be available on either the film's website, www.americanviolet.com, or on Regina Kelly's own website. 10. How Does the movie At the same time, there has been a tremendous alternative tradition, a tradition against slavery, a tradition against segregation, a tradition against racism. But this outrage only serves to make her more human, since it is always provoked in defense of her four small children. Select ALL that apply. TALKING AND PLAYING WITH MOVIES: AGES 3-8, FILM ADAPTATIONS OF NOVELS, SHORT STORIES, OR PLAYS, FICTION (SOAPS, DRAMAS, AND REALITY/SURVIVAL SHOW). Collar8. Chris Weigant blogs at: ChrisWeigant.com. The criminal justice system in America enforces the standard conduct our country finds necessary to protect all of its citizens and lower crime. Note: This set includes images of the children signing only, i, ASL American Sign Language Kids/Children signing Clothes Clothing Words Signs Clipart, Line Art + Clip Art. Students can be asked to write formal or informal essays on the following topics: This Learning Guide was written by James Frieden and Mary RedClay. Please describe Dee, the main character (protagonist) and her lifestyle or living situation in Arlington Heights. I think we would be better off if we were more concrete, we talked about real problems, and we actually used a language that got us away from these overused terms that actually dont mean that much. If you find someone, give the attorney the discussion portions of this lesson plan to guide his or her presentation. The potential to conserve valuable prosecutorial resources and for defendants to admit their crimes and receive more favorable terms at sentencing means that a plea agreement can benefit both parties. All Supreme Court quotations are from Missouri v. Frye, 42 Supreme Court Reporter 1399 at 1408 (2012). And I think the best way of addressing our race question is to just be straightforward, and be clear, and embrace the tensions, the contradictions, the complexities of race in American life. It depicts the story of an American swept into the American Revolutionary War when his family is threatened. What happens when Dee tries to get her job back? However, plea bargaining spares victims the agony of a trial and the risk of feeling very badly if the defendant is acquitted.]. Graham Boyd, the real-life ACLU lawyer who was at the center of Kelly's case (and who is also Director of the ACLU's Drug Policy Litigation Project) had this to say about the larger implications brought up by the film, and by Kelly's experience itself: What happened in Hearne is far from an isolated incident. But the movie's powerful message on the role racism plays in the Drug War will likely horrify you just the same. American Violet is not a "horror movie." shows to win money for school. Found worksheet you are looking for? Two months later, Sam is walking to Sue's house one evening. What are the ions of which it is composed? It has no monsters, zombies, or mass murderers in it. (Regina Kelly v. John Paschall) on their site, for those who are interested in the underlying case the movie is based upon. [A good discussion will include the concepts that a lenient plea bargain will not satisfy their legitimate desire to have the criminal punished. In most jurisdictions, the judge who will preside over the trial is not permitted to be involved in the plea bargain. Also included in:U.S. History 1600s-1890s ACTIVITIES Bundle: Colonial Period-Reconstruction, Also included in:Industrial Revolution in America UNIT BUNDLE, Also included in:USA state symbols clipart BUNDLE-part #2, Also included in:The Mystery of the Violet Eyes - Genetics Review Game Bundle, Also included in:The Hope Chest BUNDLE | Digital and Printable | Distance Learning, Also included in:US 50 States Flip Books Year Long Bundle Interactive Activity for Social Studies, Also included in:The Century - America's Time - Every Episode Bundle (PDF). Fmerican Violet Video Worksheet 1. Clothes6. Discuss all the people in Dees life and how each of those individuals or groups of individuals gave her the strength she needed to continue? Section Four 10 points Directions: Using your knowledge of contract formation and defenses, please review the following scenarios and state whether there is a valid contract, that is an offer, Jim is mad at Sam for stealing his girlfriend, Sue. He had a family with a wife and three young children. Evolving Bundle + Google Apps Versions, American Titans 6 Episode movie Guides - American Heroes Channel - Economics, Thanksgiving from a Native American perspective, The Century: America's Time - Unpinned (1965-1970), The Century - America's Time - Every Episode Bundle (PDF), Flowers Mini-Unit: Write the Room and Mini-Booklets, American Titans Season 1 Episode 1 Carnegie vs. Frick American Heroes Channel, Lewis & Clark Journal (Blackfoot) - Native American Primary Source w guiding Qs, Greg's Goods - Lesson Pieces - Making Learning Fun, Lewis & Clark Bundle (map activity, comics, PPT, primary sources, games, & more), High School African American History Reading - Civil Rights Movement, Part 2, High School African American History Reading - Civil Rights Movement, Parts 1-3, The Century - Americas Time: "Unpinned" (Episode 11), The Ultimate Civil War Series Episodes 1-7 Bundle Movie Guides 2012 W/Answer Key, "The Mask You Live In" (2015) Documentary Video Guide Worksheet. American Violet Analysis Mr Tab the 3rd 7/24/14 Introduction The film American Violet presents a major issue that still exists in todays criminal justice system. It was last revised on September 2, 2012. The lawyer showed the evidence to the DA who claimed that he could still get a conviction. Research the protection against illegal search and seizure found in the 4th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and write an expository essay in which you address its relationship to the issue of drug sweeps raised in American Violet. The actors portraying them in the film do an excellent job of portraying the whole spectrum of these flaws. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. 2. U.S. GOVERNMENT AP American Violet video worksheet.docx - American Violet Video Worksheet 1. What are your thoughts? This means that if a prosecutor, at any point, even after conviction, becomes convinced that a person is not guilty of the crime of which he was convicted, the prosecutor should seek dismissal of the case or try to overturn the conviction. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. 3. In other words, law enforcement actions should be based on good police work. Agreeing to the plea bargain (which would leave her with a felony record for selling drugs in a school zone) would immediately return her to her children. 6. It is not some adjunct to the criminal justice system; it is the criminal justice system. [emphasis supplied; citation omitted] [Defendants] who do take their case to trial and lose receive longer sentences than even Congress or the prosecutor might think appropriate, because the longer sentences exist on the books largely for bargaining purposes. The money saved by the plea bargain system allows the states and the federal government to devote more resources to other needs, such as schools and public health. This set includes children signing the following 33 ASL sign language words: 1. Which is the whole point. American Violet Video Worksheet 1. This could occur when a witness has a prior history that impeaches his or her credibility or because the police violated the defendants constitutional rights and important evidence is inadmissible. This set includes children signing the following ASL sign language words: Adult, Aunt, Baby, Boy, Brother (2 versions), Children, Cousin, Girl, Family, Father, Grandfather, Grandmother, Mother, Niece, Nephew, Parents, Sister (2 versions), and Uncle. As we speak, there is an African-American vice president. In return, the defendant must waive important constitutional rights and plead guilty or no contest to one or more crimes. TALKING AND PLAYING WITH MOVIES: AGES 3-8, FILM ADAPTATIONS OF NOVELS, SHORT STORIES, OR PLAYS, FICTION (SOAPS, DRAMAS, AND REALITY/SURVIVAL SHOW), Post-Viewing Enrichment Worksheet for American Violet, Additional Discussion Questions for Use When Showing the Entire Movie, Additional Assignments for Use When Showing the Entire Movie. 6. Research shows that compared to girls, boys in the U.S. are more likely to be diagnosed with a beha, This clip art bundle includes fifteen beautiful clip art images of the world's most famous artwork. In addition, as the story of Alex shows, justice, even for the innocent, can be expensive. ZIP FILE INCLUDES: Notes on the impact of westward expansion on Native Americans in the late 1800s (PDF)Worksheet with reading & questions on the reservation system, forced assimilation, and quotes from Native American leaders abo, Are all revolutions violent? After the clip has been shown implement the post-viewing discussion strategy that you have chosen. Alex was accused of shooting his former business partner in an attempted murder. The ACLU protects the Constitution by taking on cases that sometimes require it to represent people who are despised by society. Dees mother realizes, although Dee hasnt always made decisions that have helped her in life, that doesnt make her a drug dealer. The topics are numbered and identified. 7/24/14. However, how does Dee demonstrate courage when standing up to those individuals who attack her character based on stereotypes and associations? She works at a local diner, and enters hair. - She is charged with distributing narcotics in a school zone, 6. Is this good public policy? The Mask You Live In follows boys and young men as they struggle to stay true to themselves while negotiating Americas narrow definition of masculinity. View American Violet video worksheet- Yarece.docx from GOVT 2305 at Lone Star College System, Woodlands. What challenges do families have in terms of employment, voting, education and relationships with children. Thus, the prosecutors may push for plea bargains in which innocent people plead guilty to crimes they did not commit. This usually can be determined by checking on how the lawyer has treated other clients and thoroughly interviewing him or her. If Dee accepts the plea bargain, she will become a convicted felon and what else could happen to her? In these cases, a plea bargain allows the government to get a conviction with the defendant receiving some penalty, even if the likelihood of prevailing at trial is very slim. Guide the discussion to cover the following points, supplying any information that the class cannot provide: Ask the class about the interests of each stakeholder that are served by the plea bargaining system. How Does the movie begin? In addition, the inmate population in jails and prisons would explode. a definition of plea bargaining In a plea bargain, the defendant gets a reduced sentence or the dismissal of some of the charges; in return, the defendant must plead guilty or no contest to one or more crimes; when a person accused of a crime enters into a plea bargain, he or she waives certain constitutional rights; almost all criminal cases (95%, according to the U.S. Supreme Court) end in a plea bargain, not a trial; it is up to prosecutors to decide whether to charge someone with a crime or what particular crime to charge them with. They are vehicles for propaganda. - From The Representation ProjectThis video guide comes. If that isn't enough reason to go see this film, then go see it because it is an impressive and powerful piece of filmmaking that won't disappoint. Question #2: Defense attorneys usually charge a flat fee for representing a defendant in a criminal case, whether the case goes to trial or there is a plea. That can't happen in Texas anymore. This lovely Gray/Violet is the result of adding a bit of Orange and White to the Purple. Alex was innocent, but the evidence against him was very strong with an eye-witness willing to testify that he was the shooter and physical evidence that pointed to him. So while American Violet is about as far from the "horror" genre in moviemaking as you can get, audiences may indeed be horrified (or perhaps outraged) at the injustice displayed by one district attorney in Texas. Why does Dee think she is getting arrested? 4. Students need to have studied "Self-Reliance" and "Nature" by Emerson and "Civil Disobedience" by Thoreau (or excerpts of these pieces from a textbook) and preferably bits of Walden to complete the tasks required. Start the class by asking students to define plea bargaining and to describe a situation that they know about in which someone was offered a plea bargain. 2. The movie American Violet does an excellent job of demonstrating both personal (individual) and institutional racism. Set in the midst of the 2000 presidential election, American Violet tells the story of a young mother named Dee Roberts (Nicole Beharie), a 24-year-old African-American single mother 4. Kelly's website (www.reginakelly.com) is one of the best places to get information and links, or you can watch and listen to Kelly tell her own story on YouTube. Without spoiling the ending, American Violet is an excellent movie, and tells the story in a moving and heart-wrenching fashion. Do you prefer the perspective oforiginalismor do you believe more in a living constitution? The paper has to have a heading, name, class, and date; double spaced, 12 inch front, and typed. On the one hand, thats right, slavery, and segregation, and racism, and white supremacy is deeply entrenched in America. Why does Dee think she is getting arrested? Students at any level who see this section of the movie may ask to see the rest of the film, which contains several important lessons about the power of an individual to resist injustice and to right a wrong through the legal system. This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. 3. Students will learn about plea bargaining, the public policy decisions on which plea bargaining is based, and some of the problems with the practice. The movie is a fictionalized retelling of the true story of Regina Kelly, of Hearne, Texas. All images as shown Violet Crawley, the Dowager Countess Ah, the Dowager Countess. One big difference from these earlier films, however, is that the events which inspired American Violet happened in the year 2000. In order to change some of those we must first identify them. If faced with Dees situation, what choice do you believe you would make? However, he has no criminal record and he did not suffer the indignity of having to admit to a crime he did not commit. You are also agreeing to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. What are the implications of this to a justice system that relies on plea bargains? Engage your students in rich discussions, vocabulary, comprehension, character analysis, evidence gathering, prediction, and writing tasks. This lawyer did his job, investigated the case, and found evidence that Alex could not possibly have fired the shot that injured his former business partner, the trajectory of the bullet was all wrong for that to have happened. Each guide inc, Native American Experiences: Dawes Act, Reservations, Carlisle Indian School, U.S. History 1600s-1890s ACTIVITIES Bundle: Colonial Period-Reconstruction, Industrial Revolution in America UNIT BUNDLE, Colonial America- The English and Native Americans -Webquest and Video Analysis, Native plants clipart Bundle /Asian /American /Australian /European, The Mystery of the Violet Eyes - Genetics Review Game Bundle, Pan's Labyrinth / Laberinto del fauno Movie Guide for Spanish students, Six Violent Uprisings in American History, Dead Poet's Society and Transcendentalism, The Mystery of the Violet Eyes - Genetics Review Game, The Hope Chest | Distance Learning Printables, The Hope Chest BUNDLE | Digital and Printable | Distance Learning, ASL American Sign Language Kids signing Family Words Clipart Clip Art, ASL American Sign Language Kids Clothes Clothing Signs Clipart, Wisconsin State Symbols Flipbook Interactive Activity for Social Studies, US 50 States Flip Books Year Long Bundle Interactive Activity for Social Studies, The Century: America's Time - Unpinned (1965-1970), The Century - America's Time - Every Episode Bundle (PDF), The Mask You Live In (2015): Complete Video Guide, FRENCH colour/color word worksheets- les couleurs- Primary- Kindergarten, Amend Six Episode Super-Bundle (Netflix): Movies Guides for All Episodes. Answers will vary but the basic concept is that the ACLU protects all of our constitutional rights and sometimes that means protecting the rights of people we do not agree with, or even despise, as when the ACLU protected the rights of Nazis to parade in predominantly Jewish neighborhoods. American Violet holds a 75% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 59 reviews, with an average rating of 6.7/10. The website's critics consensus reads: "Though its politics are as obvious as its outcome, American Violet is an earnest docudrama about the justice system with a powerful performance from Nicole Behairie." Your right to privacy - freedom from unwarranted government intrusion into your personal and private affairs. Identifying the factors that can result in plea bargains which are either too lenient or too harsh. Mr Tab the 3rd. The compound KBr is an ionic compound. One played the role of the bad cop, correctly and repeatedly telling Alex that the government had a great case with good witnesses and strong physical evidence, and that if Alex was convicted after a trial, he would be in jail for at least 25 years and possibly for life. Owing largely to the courage and commitment of Hearne's Regina Kelly -- portrayed in American Violet by Nicole Beharie -- in the aftermath of the case, Texas became the first state in the nation to enact comprehensive reforms of the confidential informant system. Read the two plea bargaining cases decided by the Supreme Court in 2012 and write an essay about how the Courts decision may have influenced the events seen in American Violet. Students will analyze the close-reading passage and images to understand the changes that occurred during the Industrial Revolution.

Machuca Film Analysis, California Non Public Agency List, How To Apply Contact Paper Around Sink, Blooket List And Rarities, Articles A